We have finally reached that point. We finally have a well-regarded story — a movie in this case — in which the villain is the one and only showstopper. Oh sure, everybody loves Milton’s Satan. And the Joker has been much beloved twice in recent pop culture. But in both those cases, there was a hero to counterbalance the villain. In There Will Be Blood, there is no hero. There is only Daniel Plainview, a force of nothing, a supreme exemplar of depravity, on-screen. As viewers, we can feel nothing but disgust. Plainview is beyond pity.
Reader, if you’re looking for a fulfilling story, do not approach this movie. Long ago, Aristotle told us what makes a tragic story work for an audience: catharsis. There is no catharsis in There Will Be Blood. Plainview has no redeeming qualities, and he is not a great man. Since there is no joy in the movie either, you will leave this movie feeling like a pile of manure.
Unlike a great movie like Amadeus, in which the villain and main character accidentally enacts a useful morality tale for an audience, There Will Be Blood offers nothing more than the hollowness of Plainview. Sure, there is lots of vague religious symbolism, underneath the great photography. But Plainview starts out as a hideous man and grows only more hideous throughout the movie. We’ve known people like him. We do not want to be around them long. So why would we want to spend 150 minutes watching Plainview degenerate into a greedy, isolated husk of a man? Here, that is all you will see.
The counterpart to Plainview is a charismatic preacher named Eli Sunday. In typical Hollywood fashion, Sunday represents the nuttiest of the nuttiest that “Christianity” has to offer. You’d think they could throw us a decent, honest Methodist or Baptist every decade or two. But no, Sunday has to cast out the demons of arthritic old ladies and shout “I bite you, devil! And if I don’t have teeth, I gum you!” Sunday’s church is the Church of the Third Revelation, the place where the local ignoramuses go to hear the new doctrine that Sunday dreamed up two days ago. He’s a holy roller who’s only in it for money and power, and it’s a wonder that the movie doesn’t depict him as actively searching for paramours.
Sunday, like Plainview, is nothing but a vile man. Sunday, though, is the more pathetic of the two, a petty hypocrite with an annoying, boyish yell. Both Sunday and Plainview are slaves to money and personal greed, and the movie’s attempt to be intellectually brilliant is to create an ever-changing power relationship between Sunday and Plainview. Sunday baptizes Plainview so that Plainview can build an oil pipeline, and Plainview baptizes Sunday, in his own way. Need we say that neither baptizm is really effectual?
Oh, but what of the plot? Not that it matters much, since it’s the performance of Daniel Day-Lewis and the nice photography that’s on display for the credentialed critics to “ooh” and “aah” at. Plainview is an oilman who creates a town called Little Boston in the middle of the California desert, thanks to the participation of poor families like Eli Sunday’s. Plainview promises to make Little Boston into a boomtown. This is music to the ears of Sunday, who longs for a larger audience in his Church of the Third Revelation. The more people to hypnotize each week, the better.
But there’s one problem: Sunday cannot take his mind off the money that Plainview owes him, and Plainview refuses to pay. You see, the Church of the Third Revelation needs its $5000 smackeroos. As usual, the church gets greedy, and then gets conned by crooked capitalists. The Word becomes the servant of Mammon, for it can get rich no other way, so the thinking goes. Sunday thinks he can serve God and Mammon, while Plainview just thinks that God is a superstition. These are your heroes.
The movie’s final scene absolutely flounders. It punishes Sunday more than it does Plainview, whose atheism gains something of a conquest as the movie closes. It is a failed ending of what begins as a promising movie. The first twenty minutes have no dialogue, just oil prospecting. These are the best twenty minutes of the movie, with the opening shots alluding to Plato’s allegory of the cave. At the one-hour mark, the movie shifts for the worse, when Plainview’s degeneracy is obvious and painful, and by the time it flashforwards to the 1920s we’ve already long known that Plainview is utterly despicable. At least twenty minutes needs to be cut from its runtime.
The movie has almost nothing good to say about entrepreneurship or Christianity. The local townsfolk who get roped into Plainview’s schemes and Sunday’s false church are merely dupes. Everyone else is a greedy son-of-a-gun. Only Plainview’s adopted son escapes the madness, and he retreats to Mexico. Since the movie obviously attacks the idea of the self-made man, the central American myth, this flight to Mexico by the movie’s only honorable man can only mean that the American Dream is a total sham. That dream, so say says the movie, is practiced only by crooked capitalists and stupid holy rollers. Trust us, if you watch this, there will be pain.
Entertainment: 1-9
Intelligence: 8
Morality: 1 (what morality did it demonstrate?)